主题：贴，贴， -- 虽远必诛
3. Current Controlled Trials ( http:/ / www.controlledtrials.
com/);
4. Chinese Clinical Trial Register ( http:/ /
www.chictr.org);
5. Australian Clinical Trial Registry ( http:/ /
www.actr.org.au/); and
6. WHO ICTRP search portal ( http:/ / www.who.int/
trialsearch/).
Data collection and analysis
Selection of studies
Six review authors (WT, ZX, ZJ, XLX, QY, LG) performed the
searches and retrieved articles. The same review authors selected
the trials to be included in the study and no disagreements were
recorded.We retrieved the selected trials which claimed to be randomised.
We then confirmed that they were correctly randomised
by telephoning the original trial authors.
Data extraction and management
Two review authors (WT, LG) independently extracted data using
a piloted data extraction form.We extracted data on study characteristics
including methods, participants, interventions and outcomes.
There were no disagreements. The formulation contents of
included studies and herb names in three languages are described
in Table 1 and Table 2.
Table 1. Contents of the formulations used in the included studies
Study ID Contents Method of administration
Chang 2002 Did not provide any information about the contents of interventions
including Shanhanjiere Koufuye and Biaoshi
Ganmao Chongji
Each ml solution contained 2 g of raw drug material.
Each ampoule contained 4 ml. One ampoule for children
younger than 4 years of age was administered by the rectal
route; and 2 ampoules were administered for children
older than 4 years of age, 3 times a day.
Chang 2005 Jinlianhua, Daqinye, Shenshigao, Zhimu, Shendi, Xuanshen,
Kuxingren
Oral administration
Chang 2007 Gegen Qingre granule: Chaihu, Gegen, Huangqin,
Mahuang, Shigao, Xingren, Gancao
Oral water dilution
Chen 2004 Gegen, Huangqin, Huanglian, Zhigancao Oral administration
Chinese medicinal herbs for the common cold (Review) 5
Copyright 2009 The Cochrane Collaboration. Published by JohnWiley & Sons, Ltd.
Table 1. Contents of the formulations used in the included studies (Continued)
Li 1998c Qinwinkeli: the author mentioned that Qinwinkeli consisted
of 5 herbs, but just listed 2 in the paper: Shigao,
Sangye
Oral water dilution
Li 1999b Qinkailing injection: Niuhuang, Shuiniujiao, Zhenzhumu,
Huangqin, Zhizi, Jinyinghua, Banlangen 10 ml
contains 50 mg baicalin
Intravenous injection
Liu 2002 Kangbingdupian: Banlangen, Lianqiao, Shigao, Shendi,
Guanghuoxiang, Yujin, Shichangpu
Oral administration
Ma 2000b Shuanhua aerosol: Yejuhua, Jinyinghua, Yuxingchao,
Chaihu, Boheyou
Mei 2003 Yujin injection: water extraction of Yuxingcao, Jinyinghua Intravenous injection
Pan 2000 Xiaoer RiganlingKoufuye:Gegen,Taurine (Taurine is not
a herb)
Oral administration
Song 2004a TCM cream Xiaoer Tuiresan: Mahuan 100 g, Jinyinhua
200 g, Shandougen 100 g, Xixin 10 g, Bohe 100 g, Bingpian
80 g, Gancao 60 g, grind themto be very fine powder
and mix them. Take 3 to 10 g preparation with the correct
amount of vinegar tomake a creamand smear on a plastic
membrane.
Apply to the skin
Wang 1998 Jianerqinjieye: Jinyinhua, Hangjuhua, Lianqiao, Kuxinren,
Shanzha, Chenpi
Oral administration
Wang 2004 Sufeng Ganmao Koufuye: Zisuye, Qianghuo, Jinjie,
Guanghexiang, Fangfeng, Qianhu, Fuping, Fulinpi
Oral administration
Wang 2008a Yiqing Shuangjie capsule and tablet: Huangqin, Chaihu,
Rengong Niuhuang
Oral administration
Yang 2000 Huanghu Bag Tea: Huangqin, Lianqiao, Huzhang,
Shanzhima, Jinyinhua, Qinhao, Chaihu
Oral administration
Yu 1997 Chaiqin Qingre enema lavage solution: Chaihu,
Huangqin, Xixin
Oral administration
Zhang 2001 Rebining: no other information was provided
Zhang 2008 Qingyin injection: Huangqin, Yinhua Intravenous injection
Chinese medicinal herbs for the common cold (Review) 6
Copyright 2009 The Cochrane Collaboration. Published by JohnWiley & Sons, Ltd.
